The Shape of Acid

Movement Part 3: Wiggle it, Just a Little Bit

This 3-part series included only three varietals/wines. But because they could be paired and compared in three different ways, it turned out to be a nice little trilogy.

So let’s compare the final two grapes: Vinho Verde’s Loureiro and Grüner Veltliner. The descriptions of each will be familiar from the previous two sessions, but this time there’s added context: how their acid shapes compare against each other.

Quinta do Ameal Loureiro White Wine BottleLava Loureiro!

  • Wine: Vinho Verde, Lima Valley, Loureiro, 2023
  • Producer: Quinto do Ameal
  • Aroma: Less pronounced aroma than the SB, but still a good showing. Shows a greater depth of citrus with lemon zest, lemon juice, and lemon curd. Also expresses minerality, flint, and saline on the nose.
  • Flavors: Medium body with lemon zest pushing forward on the palate. A medium plus intensity of flavors including lime peel, wet stone, and citrus tartness. There is a nice balance with some earthy and bready undertones.
  • Acid:
    • The acid starts at the roof of my mouth. It trickles down my mouth. There’s almost a fizzy spritz of acid at the start. Then it moves to the tongue and then the bottom and sides of the mouth. Like an acid rinse in my mouth.
    • Master of Wine Nick Jackson in his book “Beyond Flavour” describes Vinho Verde as a “shower”. And this is exactly what it feels like: a refreshing shower of bright, refreshing acid and citrus zest.

When I drink it after the Grüner:

  • Like the Grüner after the Sauvignon Blanc, the Loureiro also increases its acid shape. The acid feels like its rinse effect has increased. Not that “power shower” feeling, but more like a lovely, continual spa-like shower.
  • I also notice that showering sensation comes a little later than before. When I first sip, it seems less acidic. I have to remain patient and focus on the acid before allowing the lemony tartness of this wine flow down my throat.

The Voluminous Veltliner

  • Wine: Engabrunn, Grüner Veltliner, Kamptal DAC, 2023
  • Producer: Steinschaden
  • Aroma: A little less aromatic, but still strong at medium plus. Also expressing green notes, but more in the realm of grass and dried thyme. Also lemon and floral notes of gardenia.
  • Flavors: Lighter body than the Sauvignon with a medium finish. Medium plus intensity of flavors, with additional notes of white pepper, and savory notes like mushroom.
  • Acid:
    • The equally high acid is very striking at first sip. But then I found myself thinking, “oh, no, its not really that acidic.” As I continue my swirl, the wine pings my mouth in specific places. And I rethink my acid analysis once again: “It is quite high!” I silently nod to myself.
    • There is this up and down nature to the acid shape. Master of Wine Nick Jackson in his book “Beyond Flavour” describes Grüner as a “rollercoaster,” which is exactly what I felt.

When I drink it after the Vinho Verde: I still notice the up and down shape, but it’s like the toddler version of a rollercoaster at a petting zoo. I have to really focus to notice the changing acid levels. It is also a bit lighter at the dip in the acid shape, but the climb to the acid apex is still strong and steep.

The Structural Summary: Bust a Move

Well, the Grüner didn’t stand up to the Loureiro’s acid intensity and shape as strongly as it did after the Sauvignon Blanc. Like nearly all the other pairings, the Grüner lessened n its shape and power. But the Loureiro was different. Its shower sensation actually increased after the Grüner, although it took a little longer to make its appearance.

So what have I learned from this little trilogy?

Acid shapes aren’t necessarily fixed characteristics of a wine. They can change depending on what you’ve just tasted. Sometimes the second wine loses its power; sometimes its movement becomes more pronounced. And sometimes it just needs a little time to get going.

Three wines, three pairings, and three rather different experiences of acid. Who knew acidity could have such a social life?

Comments

Leave a Reply